Prefer to watch? The full episode is on YouTube. Subscribe so you don’t miss the next one, and follow us on Facebook.
Quick summary: on Cozumel, in early 1519, Bernal Díaz del Castillo recalls that there were 508 men, not counting masters, pilots or sailors, with 16 horses and 11 ships. Two and a half years later, Tenochtitlan fell. From that figure comes a much-repeated idea: that a handful of Spaniards conquered America. The documentary tests it against Cortés’s letters and Bernal, focuses on Mexico — the best-documented case — and ends with Matthew Restall’s book, which turned that question into a debate.
Five hundred and eight men
The island of Cozumel, early 1519. Cortés has his men form up to be counted. Bernal Díaz would remember it years later: “We were 508, not counting masters and pilots and sailors. With 16 horses and mares and 11 ships.” Two and a half years later the Mexica capital had fallen. Is that figure enough to say that a few Spaniards conquered America?
Moctezuma’s enemies
The first clue is in Cortés’s own letters. In the second, dated 30 October 1520, he says that on the way inland he found a great wall. He was told it was the frontier of the province of Tlaxcala, whose people, he writes, were enemies of “Mutechuma” and always at war with them. At first the Tlaxcalans did not receive Cortés as friends: they made war on him. In the same letter he claims that one day more than 149,000 men fell on his camp. That figure cannot be taken at face value: Cortés was writing to impress the king, and enemy numbers in war chronicles are often inflated. What matters is what came next: Tlaxcala made peace and became his great ally. Cortés was so impressed that he compared its government to the lordships of Venice, Genoa or Pisa, because, he said, there was no single lord over all. The Spaniards did not arrive in a united empire. They arrived in a world of old rivalries.
“Every kingdom divided”
In that same second letter, Cortés says the Tlaxcalans and Moctezuma’s messengers spoke ill of one another. He wrote down his reaction: seeing the discord and disagreement between them, he took no little pleasure, because it seemed to serve his purpose well. He adds a line from the Gospel: Omne regnum in seipsum divisum desolabitur — every kingdom divided against itself will be laid waste. It is an extraordinary admission. Cortés himself explains that part of his strategy was to exploit the divisions among the peoples of Mexico.
The disease that arrived with the ships
There was another factor no army could control: smallpox. In 1520 a new fleet arrived on the coast under Pánfilo de Narváez. According to Bernal Díaz, it brought a Black man ill with smallpox, and that “was the cause that it spread and filled the whole land, from which there was great mortality”. That is Bernal’s version. Another document of the time, the report written by licentiate Lucas Vázquez de Ayllón in August 1520, instead blames Indians from Cuba travelling with the fleet. We cannot know for certain who brought the first infection, and the point is not to find a culprit. What is clear is the effect.
Bernal says that when the Spaniards returned to Tlaxcala, Maxixcatzin, one of the great Tlaxcalan lords and, he says, his great friend, had already died of smallpox. Cortés writes in his third letter that in Cholula many lords had died of the disease and that he was asked to help choose their successors. The epidemic did not only kill: it also left power vacuums, and the Spaniards stepped into the choice of new lords.
Nine hundred against a hundred and fifty thousand
The siege of Tenochtitlan, in 1521, is where the phrase “a few Spaniards” breaks down completely. On 28 April 1521 Cortés reviewed his troops: 86 horsemen, 118 crossbowmen and arquebusiers, and 700-odd foot soldiers. That is, on his own count, a little more than 900 Spaniards, because reinforcements had arrived since 1519. About two weeks later, shortly before Pentecost, the Tlaxcalan captains arrived at Texcoco with their troops. According to the count those captains gave him, they numbered more than 50,000 men of war.
In the last days of the siege, Cortés writes the sentence that sums up this story: “We were about 900 Spaniards and they more than 150,000 men.” “They” are the Indigenous allies. Both figures are his, and the 150,000 is an estimate, not a checked count. They may be rounded. But here any exaggeration works against his own glory: Cortés had no interest in diminishing his merit, and even so he recognises that his allies outnumbered him overwhelmingly. In the same passage he blames those allies for the worst violence against the defeated and says it cost him more to restrain them than to fight: that is his version, and it is a self-interested one.
The city fell on Tuesday 13 August 1521, the feast of Saint Hippolytus, after a 75-day siege, according to the third letter. Nine hundred men did not take it alone.
The book that dismantles the myth
If this appears in Cortés’s own letters, why do we still say that a few Spaniards conquered America? That is the question Matthew Restall asks in Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest, published in English in 2003 and in Spanish by Paidós in 2004 (ISBN 978-84-493-1638-8). Restall argues that the image of a few exceptional men conquering vast empires with astonishing speed is a myth. In his view, the conquest depended heavily on Indigenous allies who supplied many thousands of fighters — far more than the conquistadors themselves — and also on the participation of Africans, who often vanish from traditional accounts. That is why it is so revealing that Cortés himself, writing to claim merit from the Crown, lets those thousands of allies appear in his letters.
So: few, or many?
Is it false that a few Spaniards conquered America? If the phrase means that 500 or 900 men defeated an empire on their own, yes: it is a myth. The Spanish sources themselves show tens of thousands of Indigenous allies, a world divided by old rivalries, and a devastating epidemic. But the opposite extreme is no better. The Spaniards were not mere spectators. Cortés knew how to exploit those divisions. Horses, steel weapons and the brigantines launched on the lake all weighed in the war. And the decisions of a small group changed the fate of a continent.
There is something more: the fall of Tenochtitlan was not the conquest of America, but one of its most decisive episodes. Spanish expansion continued for decades, in very different lands and circumstances, and in it, once again, many Indigenous peoples took part. For the ships at Veracruz, continue with whether Cortés really burned them.
Frequently asked questions about the conquest of Mexico and the “few men” myth
Did a few Spaniards conquer America?
If that means 500 or 900 men defeated the Mexica empire alone, no. Cortés’s letters acknowledge tens of thousands of Indigenous allies at the siege of Tenochtitlan. The fall of that city, moreover, is not the whole conquest of America.
How many Spaniards were at the siege of Tenochtitlan?
On Cortés’s review of 28 April 1521, a little more than 900, because reinforcements had arrived since 1519. He himself contrasts that figure with more than 150,000 allies, an unchecked estimate of his own.
What role did the Tlaxcalans play?
After first fighting Cortés, Tlaxcala became his great ally. He exploits, in writing, its rivalries with the Mexica world. Without those allies, the “few men” story does not stand.
Did smallpox decide the war?
It was a decisive factor, not the only one. It arrived in 1520 with Narváez’s fleet. The sources disagree on who brought the first infection, but they agree on the death toll and on the power vacuums it left.
📚 Recommended books
Further readingLos siete mitos de la conquista española (Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest)
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
More Historia española episodes
- Who conquered Mexico? Cortés, the Indigenous alliances and the fall of Tenochtitlan (1521)
- Did Hernán Cortés burn his ships?
- The Black Legend: did Bartolomé de las Casas exaggerate?
- All episodes
Prefer to watch? The full episode is on YouTube. Subscribe so you don’t miss the next one, and follow us on Facebook.
Main sources
- Hernán Cortés, Cartas y relaciones (ed. Pascual de Gayangos, Paris, 1866), second and third letters
- Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Historia verdadera de la conquista de la Nueva España (Madrid, 1862–1863)
- Report of licentiate Lucas Vázquez de Ayllón (August 1520)
- Matthew Restall, Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest (2003); Spanish ed. Paidós, 2004
- Historia española documentary “¿Conquistaron América unos pocos españoles? El mito que te contaron” (2026)




